✦ Urza's 99
← Back
Carnage, Crimson Chaos
USD $1.39
USD foil $6.06
EUR €0.50

Carnage, Crimson Chaos

{2}{B}{R}

Legendary Creature — Symbiote Villain

Trample

When Carnage enters, return target creature card with mana value 3 or less from your graveyard to the battlefield. It gains "This creature attacks each combat if able" and "When this creature deals combat damage to a player, sacrifice it."

Mayhem {B}{R}

4 / 3

MayhemTrample
Set
Wizards Play Network 2025 (PW25 #13)
Rarity
Rare
Mana value
4
Released
2025-09-26
Artist
Lucio Parrillo
EDHREC rank
#7,058
Colour identity
{B}{R}
Finishes
Nonfoil, Foil
Served from
Local database

Commander bracket

3 +
Bracket 3 and up — Upgraded
In 4 two-card combos

Derived from card traits, not a ruling — bracket rules turn on how a deck intends to use a card. Bracket rules

EDHREC

Salt Score 0.14
How much players resent seeing this card. The scale tops out around 3.1.
Can be your commander

Combos 141

Carnage, Crimson Chaos+Phantasmal Image
{U}{B}{R}
Infinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite death triggers
Carnage, Crimson Chaos+Glasspool Mimic // Glasspool Shore
{U}{B}{R}
Infinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite death triggers
Carnage, Crimson Chaos+Flesh Duplicate
{U}{B}{R}
Infinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite death triggers
Carnage, Crimson Chaos+Activated Sleeper+Saw in Half
{B}{R}
Infinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite death triggers
Carnage, Crimson Chaos+Deceptive Frostkite
{U}{B}{R}
Infinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite death triggers
Carnage, Crimson Chaos+Activated Sleeper+Electroduplicate
{B}{R}
Infinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite death triggers
Carnage, Crimson Chaos+Activated Sleeper+Twinflame
{B}{R}
Infinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite death triggers
Carnage, Crimson Chaos+Activated Sleeper+Molten Duplication
{B}{R}
Infinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite death triggers
Carnage, Crimson Chaos+Activated Sleeper+Heat Shimmer
{B}{R}
Infinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite death triggers
Carnage, Crimson Chaos+Loyal Retainers+Umbral Collar Zealot
{R}{W}{B}
Infinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite creature sacrifice triggersInfinite death triggersInfinite surveil
Carnage, Crimson Chaos+Loyal Retainers+Goblin Bombardment
{R}{W}{B}
Infinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite creature sacrifice triggersInfinite damageInfinite death triggers
Carnage, Crimson Chaos+Loyal Retainers+Ashnod's Altar
{R}{W}{B}
Infinite colorless manaInfinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite creature sacrifice triggersInfinite death triggers
Carnage, Crimson Chaos+Loyal Retainers+Carrion Feeder
{R}{W}{B}
Infinite +1/+1 counters on a creatureInfinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite creature sacrifice triggersInfinite death triggers
Carnage, Crimson Chaos+Loyal Retainers+Viscera Seer
{R}{W}{B}
Infinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite creature sacrifice triggersInfinite death triggersInfinite scry 1
Carnage, Crimson Chaos+Loyal Retainers+Woe Strider
{R}{W}{B}
Infinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite creature sacrifice triggersInfinite death triggersInfinite scry 1
Carnage, Crimson Chaos+Activated Sleeper+Kindle the Inner Flame
{B}{R}
Infinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite death triggers
Carnage, Crimson Chaos+Loyal Retainers+Bartolomé del Presidio
{R}{W}{B}
Infinite +1/+1 counters on a creatureInfinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite creature sacrifice triggersInfinite death triggers
Carnage, Crimson Chaos+Saffi Eriksdotter+Ashnod's Altar
{B}{R}{G}{W}
Infinite colorless manaInfinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite creature sacrifice triggersInfinite death triggers
Carnage, Crimson Chaos+Loyal Retainers+Altar of Dementia
{R}{W}{B}
Infinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite creature sacrifice triggersInfinite death triggersInfinite millInfinite self-mill
Carnage, Crimson Chaos+Saffi Eriksdotter+Altar of Dementia
{B}{R}{G}{W}
Infinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite creature sacrifice triggersInfinite death triggersInfinite millInfinite self-mill
Carnage, Crimson Chaos+Saffi Eriksdotter+Phyrexian Altar
{B}{R}{G}{W}
Infinite colored manaInfinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite creature sacrifice triggersInfinite death triggers
Carnage, Crimson Chaos+Loyal Retainers+Blasting Station
{R}{W}{B}
Infinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite creature sacrifice triggersInfinite damageInfinite death triggers
Carnage, Crimson Chaos+Saffi Eriksdotter+Goblin Bombardment
{B}{R}{G}{W}
Infinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite creature sacrifice triggersInfinite damageInfinite death triggers
Carnage, Crimson Chaos+Activated Sleeper+Devastating Onslaught
{B}{R}
Infinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite death triggers
Carnage, Crimson Chaos+Activated Sleeper+Maskwood Nexus+Grub's Command
{B}{R}
Infinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite death triggers
Carnage, Crimson Chaos+Loyal Retainers+Yahenni, Undying Partisan
{R}{W}{B}
Infinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite creature sacrifice triggersInfinite death triggers
Carnage, Crimson Chaos+Saffi Eriksdotter+Umbral Collar Zealot
{B}{R}{G}{W}
Infinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite creature sacrifice triggersInfinite death triggersInfinite surveil
Carnage, Crimson Chaos+Activated Sleeper+Quasiduplicate
{U}{B}{R}
Infinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite death triggers
Carnage, Crimson Chaos+Saffi Eriksdotter+Blasting Station
{B}{R}{G}{W}
Infinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite creature sacrifice triggersInfinite damageInfinite death triggers
Carnage, Crimson Chaos+Loyal Retainers+Phyrexian Altar
{R}{W}{B}
Infinite colored manaInfinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite creature sacrifice triggersInfinite death triggers
Carnage, Crimson Chaos+Activated Sleeper+Conspiracy+Grub's Command
{B}{R}
Infinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite death triggers
Carnage, Crimson Chaos+Saffi Eriksdotter+Carrion Feeder
{B}{R}{G}{W}
Infinite +1/+1 counters on a creatureInfinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite creature sacrifice triggersInfinite death triggers
Carnage, Crimson Chaos+Saffi Eriksdotter+Viscera Seer
{B}{R}{G}{W}
Infinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite creature sacrifice triggersInfinite death triggersInfinite scry 1
Carnage, Crimson Chaos+Saffi Eriksdotter+Yahenni, Undying Partisan
{B}{R}{G}{W}
Infinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite creature sacrifice triggersInfinite death triggers
Carnage, Crimson Chaos+Activated Sleeper+Relm's Sketching
{U}{B}{R}
Infinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite death triggers
Carnage, Crimson Chaos+Activated Sleeper+Volatile Claws+Grub's Command
{B}{R}
Infinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite death triggers
Carnage, Crimson Chaos+Activated Sleeper+Arcane Adaptation+Sygg's Command
{W}{U}{B}{R}
Infinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite death triggers
Carnage, Crimson Chaos+Activated Sleeper+Amoeboid Changeling+Brigid's Command
{W}{U}{B}{R}{G}
Infinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite death triggers
Carnage, Crimson Chaos+Activated Sleeper+Stalactite Dagger+Sygg's Command
{W}{U}{B}{R}
Infinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite death triggers
Carnage, Crimson Chaos+Activated Sleeper+Blue Sun's Twilight
{U}{B}{R}
Infinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite death triggers
Carnage, Crimson Chaos+Activated Sleeper+Invasion of Alara // Awaken the Maelstrom
{W}{U}{B}{R}{G}
Infinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite death triggers
Carnage, Crimson Chaos+Activated Sleeper+Saheeli's Artistry
{U}{B}{R}
Infinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite death triggers
Carnage, Crimson Chaos+Activated Sleeper+Arcane Adaptation+Trystan's Command
{U}{B}{R}{G}
Infinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite death triggers
Carnage, Crimson Chaos+Activated Sleeper+Oko, Lorwyn Liege // Oko, Shadowmoor Scion+Trystan's Command
{U}{B}{R}{G}
Infinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite death triggers
Carnage, Crimson Chaos+Activated Sleeper+Self-Reflection
{U}{B}{R}
Infinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite death triggers
Carnage, Crimson Chaos+Activated Sleeper+Psychic Paper+Sygg's Command
{W}{U}{B}{R}
Infinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite death triggers
Carnage, Crimson Chaos+Activated Sleeper+Three Steps Ahead
{U}{B}{R}
Infinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite death triggers
Carnage, Crimson Chaos+Activated Sleeper+Xenograft+Sygg's Command
{W}{U}{B}{R}
Infinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite death triggers
Carnage, Crimson Chaos+Activated Sleeper+Volatile Claws+Brigid's Command
{B}{R}{G}{W}
Infinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite death triggers
Carnage, Crimson Chaos+Activated Sleeper+Unnatural Selection+Ashling's Command
{U}{B}{R}
Infinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite death triggers

Showing the 50 most played of 141.

Commander recommendations

Top synergy 50

Played far more in this commander's decks than elsewhere.

  1. Agent Venom 55 %+53.7 %
  2. Alesha, Who Laughs at Fate 57 %+52.3 %
  3. Maximum Carnage 50 %+48.1 %
  4. Ultimate Green Goblin 48 %+47.1 %
  5. Conjurer's Closet 49 %+44.6 %
  6. Plaguecrafter 48 %+44.2 %
  7. Accursed Marauder 48 %+42.9 %
  8. Chainer, Nightmare Adept 48 %+41.1 %
  9. Kroxa, Titan of Death's Hunger 43 %+40.7 %
  10. Scarlet Spider, Kaine 40 %+39.0 %
  11. Anger 51 %+38.0 %
  12. Lightning Skelemental 39 %+37.9 %
  13. Shriek, Treblemaker 38 %+37.1 %
  14. Alien Symbiosis 37 %+36.9 %
  15. Zulaport Cutthroat 44 %+36.1 %
  16. Morbid Opportunist 51 %+35.7 %
  17. Victimize 47 %+32.0 %
  18. Blood Artist 49 %+31.5 %
  19. Fleshbag Marauder 34 %+31.3 %
  20. Faithless Looting 58 %+30.8 %
  21. Symbiote Spawn 30 %+29.9 %
  22. Mayhem Devil 54 %+29.6 %
  23. Jaxis, the Troublemaker 35 %+28.5 %
  24. Braids, Arisen Nightmare 36 %+28.4 %
  25. Reanimate 51 %+27.5 %
  26. Big Game Hunter 31 %+27.4 %
  27. Blade of Selves 32 %+26.5 %
  28. Thrill of Possibility 44 %+25.9 %
  29. Shadow of the Goblin 29 %+25.8 %
  30. Unearth 30 %+25.7 %
  31. Villainous Wrath 26 %+25.4 %
  32. Buried Alive 30 %+25.3 %
  33. The Infamous Cruelclaw 28 %+25.2 %
  34. Undying Malice 32 %+24.7 %
  35. Green Goblin, Revenant 26 %+24.6 %
  36. Swarm, Being of Bees 25 %+24.1 %
  37. Hobgoblin, Mantled Marauder 24 %+23.9 %
  38. Saw in Half 35 %+23.0 %
  39. Azra Oddsmaker 25 %+22.1 %
  40. Tombstone, Career Criminal 22 %+21.3 %
  41. Pitiless Plunderer 34 %+21.1 %
  42. Anje Falkenrath 22 %+20.9 %
  43. Ares, God of War 23 %+20.5 %
  44. Venomized Cat 21 %+20.4 %
  45. Stitcher's Supplier 22 %+19.7 %
  46. Tortured Existence 21 %+19.0 %
  47. Ominous Asylum 21 %+19.0 %
  48. Phyrexian Reclamation 22 %+18.4 %
  49. Prison Break 18 %+17.9 %
  50. Not Dead After All 26 %+17.3 %

Most included 50

Highest share of decks running them, distinctive or not.

  1. Mountain 98 %+0.7 %
  2. Swamp 98 %+0.5 %
  3. Command Tower 81 %-4.7 %
  4. Sol Ring 81 %-4.6 %
  5. Arcane Signet 78 %-3.8 %
  6. Dragonskull Summit 67 %+2.0 %
  7. Smoldering Marsh 62 %-1.3 %
  8. Faithless Looting 58 %+30.8 %
  9. Alesha, Who Laughs at Fate 57 %+52.3 %
  10. Agent Venom 55 %+53.7 %
  11. Mayhem Devil 54 %+29.6 %
  12. Blasphemous Act 53 %+1.0 %
  13. Morbid Opportunist 51 %+35.7 %
  14. Reanimate 51 %+27.5 %
  15. Anger 51 %+38.0 %
  16. Maximum Carnage 50 %+48.1 %
  17. Blood Artist 49 %+31.5 %
  18. Conjurer's Closet 49 %+44.6 %
  19. Ultimate Green Goblin 48 %+47.1 %
  20. Plaguecrafter 48 %+44.2 %
  21. Chainer, Nightmare Adept 48 %+41.1 %
  22. Terminate 48 %+8.4 %
  23. Sulfurous Springs 48 %-0.7 %
  24. Rakdos Signet 48 %-7.7 %
  25. Accursed Marauder 48 %+42.9 %
  26. Talisman of Indulgence 47 %-7.9 %
  27. Victimize 47 %+32.0 %
  28. Foreboding Ruins 46 %+1.0 %
  29. Zulaport Cutthroat 44 %+36.1 %
  30. Thrill of Possibility 44 %+25.9 %
  31. Kroxa, Titan of Death's Hunger 43 %+40.7 %
  32. Deadly Dispute 43 %+14.3 %
  33. Blood Crypt 43 %-5.7 %
  34. Haunted Ridge 42 %+4.7 %
  35. Chaos Warp 41 %-5.1 %
  36. Scarlet Spider, Kaine 40 %+39.0 %
  37. Tainted Peak 40 %-3.6 %
  38. Lightning Skelemental 39 %+37.9 %
  39. Rakdos Charm 39 %-4.3 %
  40. Shriek, Treblemaker 38 %+37.1 %
  41. Alien Symbiosis 37 %+36.9 %
  42. Braids, Arisen Nightmare 36 %+28.4 %
  43. Bojuka Bog 36 %+0.5 %
  44. Dark Ritual 36 %-7.6 %
  45. Luxury Suite 36 %-2.9 %
  46. Graven Cairns 36 %+3.1 %
  47. Rakdos Carnarium 35 %+5.4 %
  48. Feed the Swarm 35 %-5.8 %
  49. Saw in Half 35 %+23.0 %
  50. Jaxis, the Troublemaker 35 %+28.5 %

Format legality

Rulings

  • 2025-09-19

    If a card in a graveyard has {X} in its mana cost, X is 0 when determining its mana value.

  • 2025-09-19

    If the returned creature can't attack for any reason (such as being tapped or having come under your control that turn), then it doesn't attack. If there's a cost associated with having it attack, you're not forced to pay that cost, so it doesn't have to attack in that case either.

  • 2025-09-19

    Mayhem represents an alternative cost that can be paid to cast a spell from your graveyard if you discarded the card with mayhem that turn. You must pay any additional costs the spell has.

  • 2025-09-19

    You must follow all normal timing rules when casting a spell with mayhem. For example, you can't cast a creature card with mayhem you couldn't normally cast during an opponent's turn, even if you discard that card during an opponent's turn.

An unhandled error has occurred. Reload 🗙

Rejoining the server...

Rejoin failed... trying again in seconds.

Failed to rejoin.
Please retry or reload the page.

The session has been paused by the server.

Failed to resume the session.
Please retry or reload the page.