✦ Urza's 99
← Back
Black Sun's Twilight
USD $0.51
USD foil $0.57
EUR €0.57
MTGO 0.02 tix

Black Sun's Twilight

{X}{B}

Instant

Up to one target creature gets -X/-X until end of turn. If X is 5 or more, return a creature card with mana value X or less from your graveyard to the battlefield tapped.

Set
Phyrexia: All Will Be One (ONE #383)
Rarity
Rare
Mana value
1
Released
2023-02-10
Artist
Jonas De Ro
EDHREC rank
#4,866
Colour identity
{B}
Finishes
Nonfoil, Foil
Served from
Local database

Commander bracket

1 +
Fits any bracket
No Game Changer, land denial, extra turns or two-card combos.

Derived from card traits, not a ruling — bracket rules turn on how a deck intends to use a card. Bracket rules

EDHREC

Salt Score 0.21
How much players resent seeing this card. The scale tops out around 3.1.
RecursionRemoval

Combos 31

Ashnod's Altar+Dualcaster Mage+Black Sun's Twilight
{B}{R}
Infinite colorless manaInfinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite creature sacrifice triggersInfinite death triggersInfinite magecraft triggers
55 decks Commander Spellbook ↗
Dualcaster Mage+Black Sun's Twilight+Naru Meha, Master Wizard
{U}{B}{R}
Infinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite creature sacrifice triggersInfinite death triggersInfinite magecraft triggers
38 decks Commander Spellbook ↗
Ashnod's Altar+Naru Meha, Master Wizard+Black Sun's Twilight
{U}{B}
Infinite colorless manaInfinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite creature sacrifice triggersInfinite death triggersInfinite magecraft triggers
33 decks Commander Spellbook ↗
Viscera Seer+Dualcaster Mage+Black Sun's Twilight
{B}{R}
Infinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite creature sacrifice triggersInfinite death triggersInfinite magecraft triggersInfinite scry 1
29 decks Commander Spellbook ↗
Phyrexian Altar+Dualcaster Mage+Black Sun's Twilight
{B}{R}
Infinite colored manaInfinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite creature sacrifice triggersInfinite death triggersInfinite magecraft triggers
21 decks Commander Spellbook ↗
Goblin Bombardment+Dualcaster Mage+Black Sun's Twilight
{B}{R}
Infinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite creature sacrifice triggersInfinite damageInfinite death triggersInfinite magecraft triggers
21 decks Commander Spellbook ↗
Altar of Dementia+Dualcaster Mage+Black Sun's Twilight
{B}{R}
Infinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite creature sacrifice triggersInfinite death triggersInfinite magecraft triggersInfinite millInfinite self-mill
14 decks Commander Spellbook ↗
Dualcaster Mage+Black Sun's Twilight+Yahenni, Undying Partisan
{B}{R}
Infinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite creature sacrifice triggersInfinite death triggersInfinite magecraft triggers
11 decks Commander Spellbook ↗
Dualcaster Mage+Carrion Feeder+Black Sun's Twilight
{B}{R}
Infinite +1/+1 counters on a creatureInfinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite creature sacrifice triggersInfinite death triggersInfinite magecraft triggers
10 decks Commander Spellbook ↗
Blasting Station+Dualcaster Mage+Black Sun's Twilight
{B}{R}
Infinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite creature sacrifice triggersInfinite damageInfinite death triggersInfinite magecraft triggers
9 decks Commander Spellbook ↗
Woe Strider+Dualcaster Mage+Black Sun's Twilight
{B}{R}
Infinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite creature sacrifice triggersInfinite death triggersInfinite magecraft triggersInfinite scry 1
9 decks Commander Spellbook ↗
Viscera Seer+Naru Meha, Master Wizard+Black Sun's Twilight
{U}{B}
Infinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite creature sacrifice triggersInfinite death triggersInfinite magecraft triggersInfinite scry 1
9 decks Commander Spellbook ↗
Umbral Collar Zealot+Dualcaster Mage+Black Sun's Twilight
{B}{R}
Infinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite creature sacrifice triggersInfinite death triggersInfinite magecraft triggersInfinite surveil
7 decks Commander Spellbook ↗
Phyrexian Altar+Naru Meha, Master Wizard+Black Sun's Twilight
{U}{B}
Infinite colored manaInfinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite creature sacrifice triggersInfinite death triggersInfinite magecraft triggers
5 decks Commander Spellbook ↗
Dualcaster Mage+Bloodflow Connoisseur+Black Sun's Twilight
{B}{R}
Infinite +1/+1 counters on a creatureInfinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite creature sacrifice triggersInfinite death triggersInfinite magecraft triggers
4 decks Commander Spellbook ↗
Thermopod+Dualcaster Mage+Black Sun's Twilight
{B}{R}
Infinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite creature sacrifice triggersInfinite death triggersInfinite magecraft triggersInfinite red mana
4 decks Commander Spellbook ↗
Dualcaster Mage+Bartolomé del Presidio+Black Sun's Twilight
{R}{W}{B}
Infinite +1/+1 counters on a creatureInfinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite creature sacrifice triggersInfinite death triggersInfinite magecraft triggers
4 decks Commander Spellbook ↗
Altar of Dementia+Naru Meha, Master Wizard+Black Sun's Twilight
{U}{B}
Infinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite creature sacrifice triggersInfinite death triggersInfinite magecraft triggersInfinite millInfinite self-mill
3 decks Commander Spellbook ↗
Naru Meha, Master Wizard+Black Sun's Twilight+Yahenni, Undying Partisan
{U}{B}
Infinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite creature sacrifice triggersInfinite death triggersInfinite magecraft triggers
2 decks Commander Spellbook ↗
Blasting Station+Naru Meha, Master Wizard+Black Sun's Twilight
{U}{B}
Infinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite creature sacrifice triggersInfinite damageInfinite death triggersInfinite magecraft triggers
2 decks Commander Spellbook ↗
Woe Strider+Naru Meha, Master Wizard+Black Sun's Twilight
{U}{B}
Infinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite creature sacrifice triggersInfinite death triggersInfinite magecraft triggersInfinite scry 1
2 decks Commander Spellbook ↗
Goblin Bombardment+Naru Meha, Master Wizard+Black Sun's Twilight
{U}{B}{R}
Infinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite creature sacrifice triggersInfinite damageInfinite death triggersInfinite magecraft triggers
1 decks Commander Spellbook ↗
Naru Meha, Master Wizard+Bloodflow Connoisseur+Black Sun's Twilight
{U}{B}
Infinite +1/+1 counters on a creatureInfinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite creature sacrifice triggersInfinite death triggersInfinite magecraft triggers
1 decks Commander Spellbook ↗
Naru Meha, Master Wizard+Bartolomé del Presidio+Black Sun's Twilight
{W}{U}{B}
Infinite +1/+1 counters on a creatureInfinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite creature sacrifice triggersInfinite death triggersInfinite magecraft triggers
1 decks Commander Spellbook ↗
Thermopod+Naru Meha, Master Wizard+Black Sun's Twilight
{U}{B}{R}
Infinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite creature sacrifice triggersInfinite death triggersInfinite magecraft triggersInfinite red mana
1 decks Commander Spellbook ↗
Umbral Collar Zealot+Naru Meha, Master Wizard+Black Sun's Twilight
{U}{B}
Infinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite creature sacrifice triggersInfinite death triggersInfinite magecraft triggersInfinite surveil
1 decks Commander Spellbook ↗
Shilgengar, Sire of Famine+Dualcaster Mage+Black Sun's Twilight
{R}{W}{B}
Infinite artifact tokensInfinite Blood tokensInfinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite creature sacrifice triggersInfinite death triggersInfinite magecraft triggers
0 decks Commander Spellbook ↗
Shilgengar, Sire of Famine+Naru Meha, Master Wizard+Black Sun's Twilight
{W}{U}{B}
Infinite artifact tokensInfinite Blood tokensInfinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite creature sacrifice triggersInfinite death triggersInfinite magecraft triggers
0 decks Commander Spellbook ↗
Naru Meha, Master Wizard+Black Sun's Twilight+Phantom Train
{U}{B}
Infinite +1/+1 counters on a creatureInfinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite creature sacrifice triggersInfinite death triggersInfinite magecraft triggers
0 decks Commander Spellbook ↗
Dualcaster Mage+Black Sun's Twilight+Phantom Train
{B}{R}
Infinite +1/+1 counters on a creatureInfinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite creature sacrifice triggersInfinite death triggersInfinite magecraft triggers
0 decks Commander Spellbook ↗
Naru Meha, Master Wizard+Carrion Feeder+Black Sun's Twilight
{U}{B}
Infinite +1/+1 counters on a creatureInfinite creature ETBInfinite creature LTBInfinite creature sacrifice triggersInfinite death triggersInfinite magecraft triggers
0 decks Commander Spellbook ↗

All 31 combos.

Format legality

Standard Not legal
Pioneer Legal
Modern Legal
Legacy Legal
Vintage Legal
Pauper Not legal
Commander Legal
Oathbreaker Legal
Duel Commander Legal
Brawl Legal
Standard Brawl Not legal
Historic Legal
Timeless Legal
Alchemy Not legal
Penny Legal
Premodern Not legal
PreDH Not legal
Pauper EDH Not legal
Old School Not legal
Future Not legal
Gladiator Legal
All printingsScryfall ↗Gatherer ↗Edhrec ↗

Rulings

  • 2023-02-04

    The creature card you return, if any, isn't a target of Black Sun's Twilight. You choose it as Black Sun's Twilight resolves if X is 5 or more.

  • 2023-02-04

    You can cast Black Sun's Twilight without a target (presumably with X equal to 5 or more) just to return a creature card. However, if you do choose a target, and that target is illegal at the time the spell tries to resolve, the spell won't resolve and none of its effects will happen. You won't get to return a creature card to the battlefield.

An unhandled error has occurred. Reload 🗙

Rejoining the server...

Rejoin failed... trying again in seconds.

Failed to rejoin.
Please retry or reload the page.

The session has been paused by the server.

Failed to resume the session.
Please retry or reload the page.